Atralia · 2025
Magma Ember Dusk
Magma Ember Dusk is listed as a clone of XJ 1861 Naxos. The family below is XJ 1861 Naxos first, then every clone the census tracks against it.
Accords are the family: how the scent reads overall. Notes are the materials inside it.
The family it copies
XJ 1861 Naxos
Fierte Luna
Italia
1981X
Voux Elegante
Mide Night
King Tobacco
Muharib
Insurrection II Wild
Magma Ember Dusk
Ateeq
A*Men Pure Havane11 more clones in the list below.
The verdict
How close does Magma Ember Dusk smell to XJ 1861 Naxos?
No votes yet. The scale appears once people who own both bottles have rated this pair. The first votes are the difference between a question mark and a measured score.
Rate it: spot on, close, similar, or not close. One tap. The score is the average of all votes — spot on is 95, close is 80, similar is 60, same family is 35, not close is 10.
Where these numbers come from
- Closeness. No votes cast here yet. The census score appears once people who own both bottles have voted. The closeness share from public polls is deliberately left off: it tracks who voted, not how close the liquids are.
- Scent family match. How much of Magma Ember Dusk’s scent families the product shares, computed from public note and accord lists. 50% accord overlap (broad families like citrus and woody) plus 50% note overlap (shared materials). Not a vote and not a memory test. A copied note list scores high here without proving the liquids smell alike.
- Texture notes. One line from owners who have worn both, sourced from public reviews. What they notice that no number captures: more citrus, less soap, more energy.
- Prices. No retailer has a live price for this one yet.
- Photos. Catalogue photos, hotlinked from the fragrance catalogue.
- Creator verdicts. One reviewer, one opinion. They are not census votes and they are not counted in the numbers above.
The ranking is never for sale. A house can advertise here, but it cannot buy a position in a census row.